Difficult conversation kit · Managers

Correcting someone on your team.

Their results are slipping or their attitude is a problem, and you've been putting off the conversation for weeks. Here's how to understand what's going on, then address it, without waiting any longer.

We never solve a problem we don't understand. The number one goal of this conversation isn't to sanction: it's to understand what's going on, then agree together on what needs to change.

1 Before: prepare the ground

  • Identify the specific behaviour: what, when, with what impact.
  • Check the facts: do you have concrete examples, or only rumours?
  • Separate what you observed from what you assume ("they don't care", "she's doing it on purpose").
  • Note what you don't know yet: what's going on for this person, what has changed for them.
  • Clarify what you expect instead, in observable terms.
  • Choose the right moment: in private, with a clear head, never in the heat of the moment.

2 During: the conversation in 4 steps

Describe the facts, without judgment

"Last week, [specific fact]. The impact is [concrete consequence]."
"I'm talking about facts, not intentions: this is what I observed."

Listen to their side and look for the cause

"Tell me how you see the situation."
"How do you feel about what happened?"
"Can you tell me more? What has changed for you in the last few weeks?"
"Is there something stopping you from [expected behaviour]?"

Only move to the next step once you've understood. If you discover a cause you didn't know about (workload, health, a conflict, unclear instructions), adapt what comes next.

Define together what needs to change

"Given what you're telling me, here's what I need: [expected behaviour]."
"What would help you get there? What do you suggest?"

Agree on the commitment and the follow-up

"So we agree: [specific commitment]. And on my side, I commit to [your support]."
"Let's meet again on [date] to see where we are."

3 After: the follow-up

  • Confirm the agreement in writing, even with a simple email.
  • Watch for progress and acknowledge it as soon as it shows up.
  • At the follow-up meeting, start with understanding again: "What worked? What got in the way?"
  • If nothing changes despite the agreement and your support, then clearly name the consequence, and apply it.

4 Traps to avoid

Correcting someone in front of the team to "set an example".

Attacking the person ("you're irresponsible") instead of the behaviour.

Correcting in the heat of the moment, while you're angry.

Showing up with your diagnosis already made, without asking for their side.

Threatening a consequence in the very first conversation.

Never coming back to it afterwards: a correction without follow-up is worth nothing.

Been putting off this conversation for weeks?

In coaching, we prepare your most delicate conversations together: your words, your reactions, your plan B.